From Our Archives
For earlier essays on this week's RCL texts, see Dan Clendenin, The Sheep and the Goats (2023) and Debie Thomas, You Did It To Me (2020).
This Week's Essay
By Amy Frykholm, who writes the lectionary essay every week for JWJ.
Psalm 100:3: “We are his people and the sheep of his pasture.”
For Sunday November 22, 2026
Lectionary Readings (Revised Common Lectionary, Year A)
Psalm 95:1–7a
Ephesians 1:15–23
Matthew 25:31–46
“I make drop biscuits at home,” Gary said. “And I tried that white whole wheat.” He pointed to the pantry shelf where we had five-pound bags of a white whole wheat flour. “Boy is that good. I bought a five-pound bag at the grocery store, and then I saw it here. It’s not as hard as the brown whole wheat, but it’s got more substance than the plain white flour.”
Gary often came to the church community meal for lunch. Because he lived out of town and only came in once a week, I let him break the rules and pick up his groceries for the week at the food pantry on meal days, a choice that was sometimes controversial among the staff. “By the way,” he said, “my peppers are almost ready.” He’d been drying me a blend of his hot pepper sprinkle. “I’ll bring you a jar next week.”
He looked weaker than he had two weeks before, and now he was on oxygen full time. Despite all his efforts, he looked shrunken, diminished. Cancer got him good, as he would probably say in his Western idiom.
As almost always happened, his thoughts turned from peppers to death. He’d read several of my books and knew that I had a tendency to be interested in “last things.” He’d asked me a lot of questions over the years about my views on the apocalypse and the last judgment. In my book Wild Woman, he read that I called myself a “reluctant Episcopalian.” He told me he laughed with recognition. “That’s what I am! A reluctant Mormon!” he said.
![]() |
|
Christ separates the sheep from the goats, 6th-century mosaic from Ravenna, the Church of Appolinare Nuovo.
|
Gary's goodness washed over me as we stood in the darkened sanctuary, and he surveyed his grocery options. Amidst all of our talk about heaven and hell, death, the afterlife, and the apocalypse, I sensed a gentleness in him that transcended anything that either of us could say about salvation.
But as his death approached, his reluctant Mormonism had left him somehow scared and scarred. His questions about death proliferated, and I felt a little sad that it was me he was asking. I didn’t feel like I had any answers. That day, he was thinking about his body and about his hope that his body would be allowed to rest for several days in his remote cabin before someone found him. He wanted this, he said, because he’d read about the need of the spirit when separated from the body to “settle.” That had resonated with him, and he felt that if the body was removed too quickly, there would be damage done to his spirit.
For several more weeks, he continued to bring me gifts. Pepper sprinkle in a little glass bottle, a knife set in a wooden block for the kitchen. “My cancer treatment is right next to the kitchen supply store,” he said. So he brought measuring cups, a really good potato peeler, an apple corer, and rubber spatulas of a good size and quality. His phone would go off constantly during lunch with the latest Fox News updates. Not infrequently, along with death, he wanted to talk about a conspiracy theory or two.
![]() |
|
Sheep and Goats, Italian Mosaic, 1130's, the Apse, San Clemente, Rome.
|
Then he stopped coming. I called his phone, but he didn’t answer. I didn’t know where he lived. Eventually, I got a call from someone I didn’t know. Gary had died in Denver, in the care of a friend.
As we approach the end of one season (Ordinary Time) and enter another (Advent), the lectionary readings ask us to contemplate last things. Despite its harsh rhetoric, the passage from Matthew about the sheep and goats (Matthew 25:31–46) has always been one of my favorites.
For the last judgment, Matthew imagines the “Son of Man” sitting on the throne of glory where he will separate people into two categories: the sheep and the goats. The criteria for separation are the most practical and straightforward of almost any in the entire Bible. To participate in the secret life of God, to enter into God’s realm: feed the hungry, clothe the naked, visit the sick. Concrete action is valued over either rhetoric or belief. These criteria are at once pragmatic and deeply mystical. They reveal the hidden mystery that God is in the “least of these.”
But seeing the passage through Gary’s eyes, I don’t think Gary would be comforted. If Gary and I had sat down with this passage, he would have weighed the question of judgment and found himself lacking, as he always did. Just the very thought of being lined up in front of an immortal being and judged once and for all, as the tradition has so long demanded, filled Gary with an anxiety that haunted him until his death. No, he would have said, I didn’t meet Jesus this way. I am not a sheep, so I’m clearly a goat. I didn’t do enough. I never did enough.
I never knew how to answer Gary’s “last things” anxiety, but I find myself turning away from Matthew and toward this week’s lectionary passage from Ezekiel. The image of God is not a king on a throne, but a shepherd seeking in the hills for all the lost sheep. The image of God is an intimate one, without intermediaries. “I myself will search for my sheep,” God says (34:11).
![]() |
|
Jesus separating people at the Last Judgement, by Fra Angelico, 1432-1435.
|
Instead of all gathered in one place, the sheep are scattered on many hills and rocky places. Instead of the bright, clear light of final judgment, this happens on a “day of clouds and thick darkness” (34:12). And despite the difficulty of the circumstances, God goes to find them, each with the same intensity and desire. “I will seek the lost, and I will bring back the strays, and I will bind up the injured, and I will strengthen the weak,” he says (34:16). These sheep are fed with “good pasture” and led along watercourses in images of nourishment and refreshment.
But it isn’t as if there is no judgment in Ezekiel’s image. The separation occurs between sheep and sheep. The sheep that “pushed with flank and shoulder and butted at all the weak animals” are the ones separated out and “fed with justice” instead of with grass (34:16). But the context of God’s care is so strong that the judgment feels more like necessary discipline than eternal damnation.
However we imagine last things, one thing we can know almost for certain is that our imaginations are too small for the great love of God. This is, perhaps, another truth hidden in the image of divine judgment in Matthew: love was always the only thing that mattered.
Weekly Prayer
Celtic Prayer
I lie down this night with God,
And God will lie down with me;
I lie down this night with Christ,
And Christ will lie down with me;
I lie down this night with Spirit,
And the Spirit will lie down with me;
God and Christ and the Spirit
Be lying down with me.Translated by Alexander Carmichael.
For sixty years the folklorist Alexander Carmichael (1832–1912) traversed Scotland's Outer Hebrides isles collecting and translating the traditions of its Gaelic-Catholic people. His eventual trove contained a little of everything — their ballads, prayers, proverbs, hymns, charms, incantations, runes, poems, tales and songs. Carmichael's labor of love was published in six volumes across seventy years as Carmina Gadelica ("Hymns of the Gael") Hymns and Incantations, With Illustrative Notes on Words, Rites, and Customs, Dying and Obsolete: Orally Collected in the Highlands and Islands of Scotland.
Amy Frykholm: amy@journeywithjesus.net
Image credits: (1) Brooklyn College; (2) At the Edge of the Enclosure; and (3) Wikipedia.org.




